All Articles
-
【PATENT★★】”ANTIPRURITIC AGENT” Case: A case in which the Court found that there is no motivation for using a compound stated in the cited document as an antipruritic agent on the grounds that description in the cited document is only a “hypothesis which lacks technical grounds”, and “there was plenty of room remaining for a study at the time of the priority date of the Present Invention”. (The patent at issue in this case is the same as that in Intellectual Property High Court Case No. 2020 (Gyo-ke) 10063, in which the court revoked the Japan Patent Office’s decision rejecting an application for the registration of extension of the duration of the patent at issue.)
-
【PATENT★】”COMPOSITIONS COMPRISING 2,3-DICHLORO-1,1,1-TRI- FLUOROPROPANE, 2-CHLORO-1,1,1-TRIFLUOROPROPENE, 2-CHLORO-1,1,1,2- TETRAFLUOROPROPANE, OR 2,3,3,3-TETRAFLUOROPROPENE” Case: A case in which the Court found that an amendment is considered to have added new matters (violation of requirements for amendments) on the grounds that there is no description of the reason for the necessity of the specific combination of three types of compounds which are separately described in the specification.
-
【Copyright Act ★】A case in which, with respect to a slide named “ミニタコ (Minitako)” which is a type of playground equipment imitating the shape of an octopus produced by the plaintiff for parks, the Court denied copyrightability thereof as either artistic or architectural work.
-
【PATENT★】”LEARNING IMPLEMENT” Case: A case in which the Court found that the plaintiff’s product constitutes patent infringement under the doctrine of equivalents and dismissed the plaintiff’s claim for confirmation of absence of right to demand an injunction.
-
[Patent★★] “Interleaving Paper for Glass Plates” Case: A case in which the court deemed that the invention of the prior application falls under an “invention” which is appropriate material as a cited invention (Article 29-2 of the Patent Act). If an invention lacks concreteness, or technical content of an invention is insufficiently disclosed even taking into consideration the common general technical knowledge of a person ordinarily skilled in the art, it does not fall under the “invention” and does not have an effect of excluding the later application provided for in this Article
-
【PATENT★】”BEAUTY INSTRUMENT” Patent Infringement Case: A case in which the Tokyo District Court found that the defendant’s product, even after a design change, constitutes patent infringement under the doctrine of equivalents.
-
【Trademark Act ★★】 A case in which the Court found, with respect to the trademark “HIRUDOMILD” consisting of common characters (the “Trademark”), that the Trademark is considered as a composite trademark composed of the parts “HIRUDO” and “MILD”, and when compared to the cited trademark “Hirudoid” (the “Cited Trademark”), the “HIRUDO” part is similar thereto (falls under Article 4, Paragraph 1, Item 11 of the Trademark Act), stating that it is permissible to determine the similarity by separating the parts “HIRUDO” and “MILD” and observing only the “HIRUDO” part as an essential part of the Trademark, and thus revoked a trial decision of the Japan Patent Office which determined the registration of the Trademark to be maintained on the grounds that the Trademark was not similar to the Cited Trademark (did not fall under Article 4, Paragraph 1, Item 1 of the Trademark Act).
-
【PATENT★】”GAME PROGRAM” Case (GREE): A case in which the IP High Court revoked a decision of the Japan Patent Office, finding that it is not appropriate to determine, without specifying the reasoning conducted by using known technology etc., that the invention in question could be easily conceived by a person skilled in the art because the constitution related to the difference is “mere arrangement for a game”.
-
【PATENT★】”CELECOXIB COMPOSITIONS” Case: A case in which the IP High Court recognized inventive step of a parameter invention, finding that the parameter could not be easily conceived by a person skilled in the art.
-
【Trademark Act★★】A case in which the Court found that a sound trademark containing the lyric “matsumotokiyoshi” does not corresponds to a trademark which contains the name of another person set forth in Article 4, Paragraph 1, Item 8 of the Trademark Act, and revoked a decision of the Japan Patent Office which refused an application for registration of the sound trademark because it corresponds to a trademark containing the name of another person.