All Articles
-
【Trademark Act★★】 A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court revoked a refusal decision by the JPO that the trademark in this application fell under Article 4, Paragraph 1, Item 11 or 15 of the Trademark Act. The court held that, in accordance with the actual circumstances of transaction related to the designated goods in Class 16, “information magazines concerning parts and accessories used for modifying off-road vehicles”, the trademark in the application, which is a two-line composite trademark consisting of “Jimny Fan” in Latin letters and “ジムニーファン” in Japanese katakana characters as shown below, is not similar to cited trademark 1 below, which is a logo consisting of “Jimny” in Latin letters, or cited trademark 2 below, which is a two-line trademark consisting of “Jimny” in Latin letters and “ジムニー” in Japanese katakana characters, and does not fall under Article 4, Paragraph 1, Item 11 of the Trademark Act. Moreover, the court held that there is no risk of confusion with Suzuki Motor Corporation’s goods or services bearing the “Jimny” trademark and that it does not fall under Item 15 of the same Paragraph.
-
[Patent★] Patent Administrative Litigation “Gas-System Extinguishment Facility”: A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court reversed a JPO decision on patent opposition in which a sub-citation was excessively abstracted (high-level conceptualization), and recognized inventive step.
-
[Patent★] Patent Infringement Litigation “A composition containing 2,3-dichloro-1,1,1-trifluoropropane, 2-chloro-1,1,1-trifluoropropene, 2-chloro-1,1,1, 2-tetrafluoropropane, or 2,3,3,3-tetrafluoropropene” Case: A case in which the court held that for inventions that identify impurities or byproducts for which there is no description of effects in the specification, support requirements were violated due to the lack of a description of the issue, etc.
-
【Unfair Competition Prevention Act・Copyright Act★】A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court maintained the District Court’s decision, holding that although the form of the Plaintiff’s goods is recognized as indication of the Plaintiff’s goods, the form of the Plaintiff’s goods is not similar to that of Defendant’s goods; thus, manufacture and sale of the Defendant’s goods does not fall under Article 2, Paragraph 1, Item 1 or 2 of the Unfair Competition Prevention Act; furthermore, the form of the Plaintiff’s goods is not recognized as a copyrighted work, and therefore manufacture and sale of the Defendant’s goods does not fall under copyright infringement.
-
[Patent★★] Patent Infringement Litigation “5-aminolevulinic acid phosphate salt” Case: A case in which the Tokyo District Court denied the eligibility of the cited invention yet approved the novelty of the present invention because the substance name of the invention was mentioned in the cited document, even though it was not feasible for a person skilled in the art at the priority date to carry out the invention without trial and error.
-
[Patent★★] Patent Administrative Litigation “Aminosilane” Case: A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court recognized novelty and inventive step on the grounds that the substance name was listed in the cited reference, even though at the time of priority date, it was not possible for a person skilled in the art to manufacture or obtain the substance without trial and error.
-
【Trademark act★】A case in which, with respect to a trademark determined to fall under Article 3,paragraph (1), item (iii) of the Trademark Act in the initial decision of refusal but subsequently determined to fall under item (vi) of the same paragraph in a trial decision, the court held that, although a separate notice of grounds for refusal under Article 55-2, paragraph (1) and Article 15-2 of the same Act was required as a general rule, and the trial proceedings not complying with this procedural requirement contain a defect (a violation of the law), such defect is not a ground for rescission as it is not found to affect the result of the trial decision. A case in which the court found that the trademark, “奇跡のラカンカ (kiseki-no rakanka),” written in horizontal direction (the “Trademark”), falls under Article 3, paragraph (1), item (vi) of the Trademark Act for “confectionery flavored with siraitia (other than fruit-based, vegetable-based, bean-based or nut-based)” etc. in Class 30 and the decision to maintain the trial decision is finalized.
-
【Trademark Act★】 A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court determined that the registered trademark, which the Defendant owns, for the designated goods of class 30 “Gummi Candy” and indicating the Japanese characters “地球グミ” [chikyu gumi] in standard characters falls under Article 4, Paragraph 1, Item 10 of the Trademark Act, holding that the term “地球グミ” of the cited mark is widely recognized among consumers of gummi candies, including young people, as indicating the gummi candies “Trolli”, “Planet Gummi” or “Blue Planet” related to the business of the Plaintiff, who is an importer and distributor in Japan, or of the foreign manufacturer, by the date of the examination decision at the latest (February 22, 2022), and that there were no arguments or evidence that the trademark fell under the same item as of December 16, 2021, the filing date of the application (Article 4, Paragraph 3 of the Trademark Act), and rescinded a JPO decision that dismissed the request for a trial for invalidation of a trademark registration.
-
【Trademark Act★】A case in which the Intellectual Property Hight Court determined as similar (falling under Article 4, Paragraph 1, item 11 of the Trademark Act) comparing the following cited trademark with the part “O!Oi” of the following registered trademark by separating and observing the main elements of a composite trademark, and revoked the JPO’s decision which determined as dissimilar (not falling under the above provision).
-
[Patent★★] Patent Administrative Litigation “Antigen Binding Proteins to Proprotein Convertase Subtilisin Kesin Type 9 (PCSK9)”: A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court rejected the logic that the support requirement is satisfied by reciting a particular effect in the claim concerning a functionally expressed reach-through claim unlike the final judgment in the previous case.