Articles on Domestic
-
【Unfair Competition Prevention Act★】A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court dismissed the appeal of the Appellant (first-instance plaintiff: X), holding that the act of the Appellee (first-instance defendant: Y) of using indications in advertisements for the EH-HA0G model hair dryer (Y’s product), including “nanoe MOISTURE+ moisturizes hair 1.9 times better,” “Amount of moisture generated compared to a conventional device: 18 times,” “preventive effect against hair color fading,” “helping to prevent friction damage” (each of Y’s indications) does not fall under Article 2, Paragraph 1, Item 20 of the Unfair Competition Prevention Act.
-
[Patent★] Patent Administration Litigation “Lamp and Lighting Device” Case: A case in which the court recognized a support requirement for samples that only marginally failed to meet the effect stated in the specification, based on fitting deviations in measured data, as they were deemed to achieve “roughly the desired” effect.
-
[Patent★★] Appeal Court for Patent Infringement “Functional Water” Case: A case in which the court of first instance determined a patented invention to be invalidated for lack of novelty based on a publicly worked invention, but for which the court of appeal accepted the defense regarding the correction of patent raised during the appeal proceedings, and as a result, the patent holder won the case on appeal (the corrected patent was deemed valid).
-
【Tort law★】 A case in which the Appellant had been streaming a “shogi” (Japanese chess) tournament for a fee with permission from the Japan Shogi Association, and the Appellee, as an individual viewer, had been reproducing the moves in the shogi tournament on a board and simultaneously streaming the moves for free to shogi fans on YouTube and other platforms. The Osaka High Court reversed the decision of the first instance court, in which the court partially recognized the Appellant’s request for an injunction and damages on the grounds of the Appellee’s defamation of business (Article 2, Paragraph 2, Item 21 of the Unfair Competition Prevention Act), holding that the Appellant’s request for Google and others to remove the content on the grounds of copyright infringement with regard to the live streaming videos does not constitute “infringement of [the] business interests” (Article 3 and 4 of the Unfair Competition Prevention Act) of the Appellee
-
Patent★ Patent Administrative Litigation “Program” Case: A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court recognized a sub-cited invention as a “higher level concept” and denied the inventive step of a “Disclaimer”
-
【Trademark Act★】 A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court maintained the JPO’s decision of refusal, holding that a trademark as applied for, relating to a three-dimensional form of a tooth model fixing plate with support stand for dental work, falls under Article 3, Paragraph 1, Item 3 of the Trademark Act and does not fall under Paragraph 2 of the same Article.
-
【Unfair Competition Prevention Act★★】A case in which the Nagoya District Court, using a judgment method similar to a filtration test, denied that technical information disclosed by an employee after abstracting and generalizing the information was of a confidential nature, which is a requirement of trade secrets, and handed down a full acquittal.
-
【Trademark Act★】 A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court held as follows: The court found that each of the Defendant’s indications posted on each webpage of this case does not fall under “advertisement materials … relating to … services” (Article 2, Paragraph 3, Item (viii) of the Trademark Act) and does not infringe on the function of source indicatior of the Plaintiff’s trademark. The court also found that, for the same reasons, the posting in question does not fall under Article 2, Paragraph 1, Item (i) or (ii) of the Unfair Competition Prevention Act. In conclusion, the court revoked the decision by the court of first instance in which infringement on the Plaintiff’s trademarks was found, and dismissed the Plaintiff’s claims.
-
[Patent★] Patent Administrative Litigation “Training Apparatus” Case: A case in which the Intellectual Property High Court recognized an inventive step on the ground that it was not permitted to extract a part of a configuration from an embodiment of a cited reference and recognize it as a cited invention; moreover, it was not easily conceivable to consider removing parts other than the part in question.
-
【Unfair Competition Prevention Act★★】A case in which the Sapporo High Court denied the confidential nature of information recorded in an electronic ledger of customers, then overturned the District Court conviction and handed down a full acquittal.