Article by Patent Attorney Yoshimitsu Kudo, “Generative AI Models as Infringing Copies,” Published in the November 2026 Issue of Intellectual Property Management
Title:
Noteworthy Overseas Court Decision No. 121 [UK]: Generative AI Models as Infringing Copies
Author:
Yoshimitsu Kudo
Journal:
Intellectual Property Management, November 2026 Issue
Publisher:
Japan Intellectual Property Association
Publication Date
November 15, 2026
Abstract:
This article examines the use of training data in generative AI models, the legal treatment of model weights, and the relationship between watermarks appearing in output images and trademark infringement, with reference to the UK High Court’s decision in Getty Images v Stability AI. Based on the technical understanding that Stable Diffusion does not internally store its training data, the Court held that the model itself did not constitute an “infringing copy” under UK copyright law and therefore rejected the claim of secondary copyright infringement. On the other hand, where Getty Images or iStock watermarks appeared in certain output images, the Court found that the AI developer had used the marks as trademarks. With reference to the UK Government’s report on copyright and AI published in March 2026, this article also compares the UK position with Article 30-4 of the Japanese Copyright Act, which permits certain uses of copyrighted works for purposes other than the enjoyment of the ideas or emotions expressed therein, and outlines practical considerations for the use of generative AI.
